Our world is inhabited by billions and billions of people, and like snowflakes, these people all have things about themselves that make different from others. In the essay, “The Struggle to Be an All-American Girl”, which can be found on page thirty of the textbook, The Prentice Hall Guide for College Writers, the author, Elizabeth Wong, discusses her hardships that she faces in her life. Mainly, her issues were focused on what her true identity was. She was brought up in America, but was born to Chinese parents. Although she was used to American schooling, and American customs, she was forced to attend a Chinese school as well. By being forced into two totally different types of schools, she became aware that although she was born Chinese, she truly enjoyed her status as an American much more. It was as if she embraced her role as an American, but felt distant from her Chinese ancestry. This brings up the question, if you are multicultural, like many of us are, which culture would you feel the closest bond to? While many of us are born into families of multiple cultures, it can be a confusing experience to distinguish between the bonds we have to each one.
I was born into an American family, and primarily consider myself an “All-American Girl”. While I may have been brought up as an American, my family ancestry reaches many parts of the world. From what I have researched, my ancestors came to America from France, Ireland, Italy and probably a few other parts of the world. Sure, it’s true that I’ve never once stepped foot in any of these places, but the fact still remains that I am linked to these nations in one way or another. The problem that I have with the story about Elizabeth Wong, is that she basically hates her true identity. In the story it never mentions that she has been to China, but yet, she complains about learning more about her culture. I simply cannot understand why you wouldn’t want to learn more about your ancestry, or why it would ever be a nuisance to a person. Her annoyance towards her Chinese culture could be due to the fact that she was forced to study, and it left her little time to do things that “normal” children would be doing. As a child, I probably would have thought the same way, but now as a young adult, I find family history and ancestry to be very fulfilling. I take interest in knowing that my ancestors are not all from one nation, and I believe it makes for some awesome diversity.
While some people, such as Elizabeth Wong, shy away from embracing their culture, I believe that people should be proud of where they come from. There should be no embarrassment, or fear of judgment, because as we know, America is comprised of immigrants. Elizabeth may just have been too young to truly appreciate where her ancestors have brought her, but I believe in time, she will more fully understand how important her culture really is. Ironically enough, I found a quote about diversity that was said by Hu Jinato, who is the paramount leader of the People’s Republic of China. Hu Jinato said, “Diversity in the world is a basic characteristic of human society, and also the key condition for a lively and dynamic world as we see today.” Truthfully, I don’t know if anyone could have summed up our world better than that.
Thursday, January 21, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I have enjoyed reading what other people got out of the same story read and wrote about! While you took a much different approch to reviewing the story than I did, I agree with much of what you said. I think my favorite line was "While some people, such as Elizabeth Wong, shy away from embracing their culture, I believe that people should be proud of where they come from." I am sure this is something many people struggle with.
ReplyDeleteYou have a very thought provoking line "which culture would you feel the closest bond to?" I know a family friend whose parents came through Ellis Island from Italy. She knows even less about the country than I do. It simply wasn't something they talked about. I believe the phrasing was "We're American now." Just how much old wisdom have we lost because we're american now?
ReplyDeleteI really like where you state the different ancestries you have came from and that even though you have never stepped foot in any of these places, you still feel apart of them. I agree with this 100%, in a way you originated from these people and there culture and you should always be proud of that!
ReplyDeleteI like that you put alot of yourself into the blog. I read this story as well, she sort of comfused me on the last two lines. She hated the Chinese schooling but hated being American? I liked where you came from and you made ver valid points.
ReplyDeleteI completly agree with your view of the article. I can't understand why someone wouldn't want to know more about their culture. Just because she was chinese it didn't make her unAmerican. Maybe she was too young to understand the importance in knowing about yourself.
ReplyDeleteI totally understand what you're saying when it comes to respecting your own cultures and being eager to learn about them. However, it seems that the author learned more about the American culture before she was forced to learn about her own. Also, because her brother is so focused on the english language then I assume that he probably has much similar feelings as his sister. If her parents hadn't forced the Chinese culture upon their children then they might actually respect their own culture much more.
ReplyDeleteQuite a few comments imply that the Asian culture is "her culture." That could mean the people reading it are missing the point: she doesn't claim it as her culture, or she's at least struggling to decide what "her culture" is. Well written, but very biased--you knew that, I hope!
ReplyDelete